I recently played a solo game with my wife as a kind of two-headed player. This really got me thinking about how solo games are presented in our hobby, and I began writing an article that tried to categorise different types of solo game and come up with a kind of family tree for them.
Then I ended up writing so much specifically about Enchanted Ivy by Sarah Joshua, a recent arrival published by Allplay, that this article kinda turned into a review of that game instead.
Here was my effort to map out a few different varieties of solo game:
Placement games - Enchanted Ivy, A Gentle Rain, Dorfromantik, A Dragon’s Tale
Choose-your-own-adventure - Vantage, Sleeping Gods, Cozy Stickerville
Hand or Deck management - For Northwood, Micro Hero Hercules
I definitely have thoughts about all these ‘solo’ games now, so I look forward to being able to get the rest of the article that’s in my head down on paper. For now though, let’s talk about…
Enchanted Ivy by Sarah Joshua
Enchanted Ivy is the very reason I started thinking about this article. Excited by this recent solo-only offering from Allplay, I streamed my attempt to learn how to play the Prologue over on our Discord channel. However, by focussing on just the Prologue (which is an excellent tutorial for the game) I took away an impression that the game was much simpler than it really is, and nearly missed a real gem.

Every scenario of Enchanted Ivy has you draw guests from a bag, and place cards 2 at a time - one with a balcony for a guest, the other as a blank wall. These guests have different scoring rules, so in the Prologue you have:
The Monk who does not like to be touched. He wants all cards touching him, even the diagonals, to be empty walls.
The Mystery Knight who just wants to have a peaceful bath with his rubber ducky. They want no guests, nor the main door of the inn on the same floor as them.
The Painter, who wants to have subjects to paint. You can choose to score to the left or to the right, and can score 9 points if the 3 closest cards in that direction are all occupied with guests.
The Scarecrows. To make the Prologue last a few more turns without overwhelming you with rules, the bag of guests is bulked out with Scarecrows who do not have scoring rules of their own, they are just guests who interact with the Monk, Mystery Knight and Painter’s rules.
One subtlety with the guests - you draw them from the bag at random but you always have 2, so whilst you have to place one of them each turn, you can hold the other back until you build the ideal spot to place it. Just enough control over the randomness to feel like you earned your final score.
On top of this you will score based on how many patches of ivy you create. Every card has some ivy on it, and you maximise the ivy score by keeping all the ivy connected. Each disconnected patch will rob you of a few points.
The ‘problem’ - if you can call it that - is that the Prologue is easily ‘solved’. So, to get the maximum score on the Prologue, you need the Monk isolated from everyone, the Mystery Knight on an empty row off the ground floor so the door doesn’t upset him, and the painter on the edge of a row looking down at 3 guests to paint. Keep the ivy in one chunk and that’s a maximum of 48 points.3
My point is that’s possible. This is a maximum score that you can feasibly reach, at which point you’re done with the scenario - there’s not really anything more it can teach you4.

A later scenario of Enchanted Ivy with much more going on than the Prologue does - and boy does it hit the sweet spot!
In fact, you only need 30 points to pass the Prologue (and the game doesn’t stop you from proceeding even if you do miss the target score) but that maximal 48 is reachable. The big mistake I made was not playing Scenario 1 proper before forming an opinion on the game - because as it turns out, the Prologue was the last time I thought perfect play was even possible!
So, I put Enchanted Ivy away, idly thinking I could use it to refine my live streaming skills in the future, or crack it out whilst I was waiting for something else to happen. It was only when my wife mentioned something about Enchanted Ivy - I think they saw it on the impressive Allplay stand at SPIEL - that I mentioned we have it and I could teach it to her.
My wife couldn’t get enough
Believe me, after teaching the mechanics of the game to her via the Prologue, we were off. We did the first 3 scenarios in one sitting back to back, before coming straight back the following day for 3 more, concluding the first Act (the scenarios are split into 2 books probably for practical printing purposes more than anything else).
I really appreciated the time we were spending playing this solo game together. I don’t think it ever crossed my wife’s mind to want to play it on her own. It didn’t matter that the game was advertised as a single-player game, it tickled just the right spot that we could play together, me mostly making sure all of our moves were legal and scored correctly, but also offering things I’d spotted about the scenario - and this is, I think, the key point of the article.
There is quite a lot to pay attention to once the complexity of the scenarios ramps up - and you are subject to the whims of the random guest draw from the bag and the random ivy shapes (and colours!) coming from the deck of cards. Having one person keep an eye on the best place for an incoming guest whilst the other player checks you’re not messing up the scoring condition for an already placed guest can work really well.
Just know, if you’re that kind of couple, who has final say on actually placing the cards and guest. With each scenario lasting a maximum of 10 turns, you can always change who is in charge for the next one2.
It’s complex enough that even working out a theoretical maximum score is hard,1 but that’s great as the game isn’t asking you to do that. In a genius move, the designer gives you 2 target scores, one for a successful conclusion, and another for a high score - both rewarded with stickers for the butterfly garden. Show me a solo gamer that doesn’t like earning stickers, and I’ll… well I don’t know because it’ll never happen :P
There are challenges baked into each scenario as well, which can be difficult enough to fulfil, even before accounting for the fact that they only count if you also meet the success condition5. Better yet, solved challenges reward you with doors and access to new abilities, which give you a reason to revisit past scenarios and try once more to get that high score!
An aside on the Lost Ruins of Arnak - The Missing Expedition
My wife and I also, finally, finished our playthrough of the co-op campaign of Lost Ruins of Arnak - from the Missing Expedition expansion.
The campaign was originally a solo one that you could play mostly with cards from the base game, plus a small number that you could print out yourself. Existing purely as this digital download item, it was a great optional extra to get a different gaming mode out of Arnak for no extra cost. I started to play it, but I don’t remember how many chapters through I got, when I heard that it was being officially released as an expansion - and being made co-op to boot!
So, I abandoned my solo run and went two player co-op instead. Now, don’t get me wrong, we had fun playing the 6 chapters and did achieve a good ending, but wow did it feel difficult. Much like our dalliance with the Everdell Duo campaign, this got difficult and felt something of a grind at points - it took us nearly a year to play the 6 games!

The whole time I couldn’t help but feel that this might actually have been better as a 2-player solo experience, and there’s one design factor that stood out to me. In an effort to make the campaign work in both solo mode and co-op mode, the achievements and special rules in each chapter had to be rebalanced. Obviously if 2 people are collaborating they will do more than one player alone in terms of drawing cards, defeating guardians, spending coins etc.
However, I really feel like this was designed as a solo campaign, and the co-op side was tacked on later. I feel this way because most of the co-op targets are simply double the solo targets, whereas the game doesn’t scale simply like that. For example, in one scenario you are rewarded for buying expensive items. Playing as one player, you could take a strategy which focusses on obtaining money, or choose a character suited to obtaining items, and by focussing this way hit this achievement. However, it’s much harder to have both players focus on the same thing in a game that’s at least partly worker placement, because if one player pursues a certain strategy, it’s de facto harder for another player to also do that!
If I ever play through the Arnak campaign again6 I will certainly let you know! For now though I am looking forward to getting a chance to play the game competitively once more - there are boards I haven’t tried in here because they don’t feature in the campaign! Sometimes you just don’t want to face a challenge that a designer set you no matter how talented that designer is - you want to face the challenge that is a real, live, reactive opponent.
Maybe give solo games another look
There you have it - one example of a game that’s marketed as a solo experience but can very easily be enjoyed by 2 players working together anyway, and another that felt like a solo game trying so hard to fit a 2-player shell that it contorted itself out of shape.
Let me know if you’ve had any similar experiences, either in the comments on this article or head to our Discord server and share your views!
If you enjoyed this newsletter, we’d appreciate it if you would forward it to a friend. If you are that friend, welcome to the newsletter!
You can also join our community Discord where we play games and discuss gaming ideas
You can late pledge to the already successful Kickstarter campaign for our first game, Which Witch?
And finally you can contact me at [email protected] if you need to tell me anything that I might not know!
1 The guests’ demands begin to contradict each other, so finding the optimal placements for guests becomes almost impossible, especially as to meet those placements you are relying on the guests coming out of the bag in a certain order. Thankfully, the game is only asking you to observe the synergies that exist between the guests you have already placed and the guests you have available to place this turn.
2 This is explicitly how Dorfromantik and A Gentle Rain handle their solo/co-op distinction. You take it in turns to draw a tile and place it, and - whilst other players can offer advice if they want - the player drawing the tile has the final say on where to place it. It just never functionally matters which player placed which tile - it’s a group project all scored together at the end.
3 I am claiming this from memory, if I’m wrong and you have scored more than 48 in the Prologue let me know!
4 Now I understand why it’s the Prologue!
5 Yes, we beautifully engineered a solution to a challenge in Scenario 6 before realising we were 3 points short of the target…
6 Either as solo or multiplayer-solo.

